April 9, 2025

49 thoughts on “I Grilled Top Finance Experts on the UK Budget 2024

  1. Incredible what communists are here talking.. you make me sick

    Pension iht?

    Ok. My dad was hard working all life and saved to oension to make sure future generations will benefit. He sacrificed his tkme on this planet with me to make sure my future will be brighter than his. I never had father. He was already at work when i woke up, he was still at work when i was going bed.

    Now government unlawfully makes worst law break – law doesn't work backwards, and change rules of game destroying my father's plan, his work, his sacrifice, mine single parent childhood and you dare to speak its ok to tax it now?

    Disgusting red communists. Shame on your mothers for breeding such a creatures

  2. Spending on healthcare does lead to growth, as it reduces loss of workers to sickness over time. I do feel sometimes accountants look at numbers as accountants. When it is important to look at financial policy as a strategist and tactician. Justice spending helps to support contract law which is business. Health spending will go down overtime, the high upfront is due to just how behind healthcare is, a lot of people need care. We see spending everywhere on road works, that will be over by years end and the money can be rediverted in following years to other elements. – Denning New Economic Policy – Healthcare will always look like a cost, but if the groundwork is covered, actually it will get cheaper as the less expensive treatments will be less common.

  3. This whole argument that "people pay tax" is so disingenuous when company directors can access the value of their company without directly drawing as a taxable revenue, or via "tax efficient" methods like dividends. We need to see legally enforced indexation for PAYE like Belgium has.

  4. Also the idea that salary sacrifice would be a "win win" doesn't make sense as the only people who can afford to accept salary sacrifice are already earning above the upper limit for NIC anyway.

  5. So nice to hear three incredibly smart individuals discuss this important subject without talking over each other and trying to score points, as they do on political programs. I also agree with Paul’s comment at the end re a penny off of beer – Clearly a complete smoke screen by the government and attempt to win over those not remotely interested in the broader economy.

  6. Pensions are a scam. The government encourages you to pay into one for 40 years, then they tax it for inheritance purposes, and lastly they raise the Pension age (helping you to die earlier In retirement). So a lot of people will probably die off early and end up handing over a chunk of their estate in taxes.

  7. My partner she’s a part time teacher in a private school for kids with special needs and mental health.

    So she’s been backstabbed twice by this government with this budget and the VAT of private schools.

    Immigration more and more is becoming part of the conversation. It just isn’t nice to live in this country and it’s getting harder and harder too.

    Sadly tied with a 30+ year mortage, family and a 2 year old.

    The UK needs to improve, NOW.

  8. 90% of ppl don't take responsibility for their pension and just do the same thing regardless of the changes so locking it to stop noise seems just politics

  9. Oh Paul's house has made more than him and he's bitter to the farmers. Get a grip, farming is dieing out and covers and enormous proportion of our land and protects food security, most people ruin the country and farmers generally keep it green and pleasant for the 99% of the rest of the country to throw their McDonald's wrappers into their working land

  10. Both our parents will pay inheritance tax and they are both vehemently against their very hard worked for savings to give for us… Problem I have is saying – spend it don't give it to me

  11. There's one thing I still don't quite understand. Making it harder/more expensive for landlords, decreases the amount of houses in the renting market. But it also frees up houses that people can buy as homes and not assets. So why does it seem like it only ever drives rents up?
    Governments only make it harder for landlords by raising costs that they pass on to renters… who need the house to live.
    Why can't they limit who can buy second homes, like, non residents. or create pockets around the country where they can only be bought for occupation?!
    It just drives me insane that renters always end up paying.

  12. Despite challenging times for most businesses, the Information Technology sector—especially Managed Service Providers (MSPs)—continues to thrive. Our income 🤑đŸĨŗ😎from selling IT support services remains strong, even as other industries struggle.😒

  13. What an insightful video. I have been waiting for someone to discuss the budget in detail and at the same time easily digestible since…the budget (haha). Also I have to complement your guests . Such lovely and professional characters . Amazingly informative and useful video. Thank you

  14. Thank you for a wonderful pod with some really balanced views from some well informed people. Thanks again Damien, from a Brummie who has most of his family from Southport and Liverpool 🙌đŸŧ

  15. As a contractor paid via umbrella company, employer national insurance is deducted from my wage (and my wage is average). So my pay from april will be significantly less..but us contractors are the forgotten few who are directly effected by employers NI

  16. Paul's take on landlord taxes is so incoherent and he nearly reaches the point then drops it. He acknowledges that some landlords will be forced to sell their homes which will free up houses for the market, and then points to how the people renting will feel the effects in hightened rent prices because there will be fewer houses available to rent. What's the common denominator there Paul? Did the rent prices raise themselves? Was it magic? Oh wait, the landlords raised them. Private landlords should not exist, they're just leeching off of the working class. You can point to the higher occupation of rented housing all you like to solve the problem all that really means is you're arguing for societies poorest to be living in s*** appartments and house shares forever.

  17. If a lot of jobs are going to be taken over by AI, what's going to happen to all those workers (often lower-paid workers) that just got displaced? Are they all going to now have to survive on benefits? Because this isjust going to get worse in the future.

  18. It sounds silly and I’m not an economist but cutting jobs might be a good thing? We have a tremendous number of low skilled, low productivity jobs dragging us down because employers aren’t incentives to change there hiring practices? Would increasing there costs force them to adapt and potentially be more productive? What I’ve said is probably rubbish but I’m wondering if any of that is true. Like for example could these supermarkets look at investing in new technology, or systems to handle there warehouse stock? Insteading of employing 5 8 hour staff

  19. Some interesting points.

    The minimum wage especially for the younger has risen by a huge amount, I get it everyone wants a pay rise, but let’s see if youth unemployment rises. I fear it will have long term effects on the low skilled and the young getting their first jobs.

    The bank of mum dad would be less important if it was easier to just build houses, it’s the planning restrictions that cause this wealth inequality.

    Agree stamp duty is stupid, it should be abolished, I’d hate to say it but maybe just put up council tax slightly at least I won’t face a tax build if I want to move house it’s ridiculous, buying and selling houses is already expensive enough.

    They won’t provided the right incentives in the NHS it’s too big, it needs splitting up, or allowing for private competition to enter the entire health sector where consumers can choose for themselves, we need small nimble agile startup health providers which can disrupted the industry and innovate and produce that productivity enhancement without the interference of bureaucrats and committees.

  20. The government spends nothing on wind and solar it’s all private investment? What about the contracts for difference subsidies for renewables? And I’ve had to pay for it through my bills in the renewable obligation certificates?

    Electric cars all private investment? The main reason for this was the huge reduction in Benefit in kind tax on these vehicles, the reduction in congestion and clean air zones, etc these are hidden subsidies, but it’s real revenue the government didn’t get by waving these charges on electric vehicles. Then add to that the ÂŖ15K fines car dealers will have to pay if they don’t sell more the 22% electric vehicles.

    Heat pumps are also ridiculously expensive and so that’s a huge cost the tax payer is going to have to pay if we’re forced into them. I would argue whether the capital co2 costs are outweighed by the potentially low co2 costs in running them, but again that all depends how much renewables we can actually introduce into the grid without making it unreliable.

    These are especially huge costs for the least well off.

  21. Why did Paul Johnson feel the need to chuckle when Clare Barrett stated that redundancies may be an outcome of the Employer's NIC increase ? Perhaps because more people will have little choice but to try and survive as independent workers…the very workforce group that he has been advising government to persecute for years (IR35) and crush out of existence.
    Maybe he'll laugh out loud when inherited estates are robbed as a a result of pensions being included in IHT (the double taxation, IHT plus income tax on drawdown, is scandalous).
    No matter. He was clearly so bored by financial state of working people's lives that he clearly fell asleep, more than once.

    This will be proven to be a disastrous budget, on multiple levels, especially the outcome of low growth and reduced employment which are the opposite of what the UK desperately needs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *